Coinbase’s Chief Legal Officer (CLO) Paul Grewal recently criticized the U.S. court’s ruling in favor of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The judge classified certain cryptocurrency assets traded on secondary markets as securities. The ruling is part of an insider trading lawsuit against a former Coinbase product manager and his relatives.
In 2022, the SEC charged Coinbase’s former product manager Ishan Wahi, his brother Nikhil Wahi, and close friend Sameer Ramani with securities violations for insider trading of certain crypto assets.
The SEC alleged that the former Coinbase employee “tipped off” his brother and friend about the exchange’s upcoming listing announcement, which he helped coordinate. Last year, Ishan and Nikhil Wahi settled their allegations with US regulators and Ramani seemingly left the country.
Cryptocurrency asset trading in secondary markets classified as securities
The most recent development in this case involved a third party being indicted by the SEC. Sameer Ramani, a friend of the Wahi brothers, allegedly made illegal profits of $817,602 by illegally trading tokens provided by Ishan Wahi.
Wahi’s friend is still very confused because he did not appear in court or respond to the First Amendment Complaint (FAC). After receiving approval for the concept of alternative service, the SEC notified Ramani and his criminal defense attorney directly via email and WhatsApp.
The SEC sought default entry as follows in court documents:
Despite being served pursuant to a court order, Ramani neither appeared on the matter nor responded to the FAC. Accordingly, on October 19, 2023, the SEC filed a Notice of Default (Dkt. No. 113), which the Clerk of Court entered on October 26, 2023 (Dkt. No. 114). The SEC will now proceed with a final default judgment against Ramani.
As a result, the court entered a default judgment based on the evidence presented by the SEC. According to the U.S. regulator, the tokens Ramani traded were investment contracts and therefore securities “each token involved the investment of money in a common enterprise with a reasonable expectation of profits derived from the efforts of others.”
As stated in the document, the court’s analysis remains the same and extends to tokens that Ramani trades on secondary markets.
The Ninth Circuit explained that whether goods purchased on the resale market are investment contracts depends on a determination of “the economic realities of each transaction” and “what investment package was actually offered.”
The court finds that the issuer of the tokens Ramani traded continued to offer “the profitability of the tokens as they were traded in the secondary market,” and “therefore, under Howey, all cryptocurrency assets purchased and traded by Ramani were investments.” contract.”
Coinbase’s CLO Criticizes SEC’s Strategy
Paul Grewal, Coinbase’s CLO, expressed his opinion on the matter on X (formerly Twitter). post. When asked his opinion on the SEC ruling on User X, Grewal responded, “I don’t think much of it at all.”
CLO explained in the As a result, the judge must accept everything in the complaint as fact, “no matter how outrageous or patently false it may be.”
All of this means that the SEC is facing a completely open door as it pursues a default. This is an example of why courts generally do not grant collateral estoppel effect on default judgments in other cases. They have no precedent or persuasive value. 5/6
– paulgrewal.eth (@iampaulgrewal) March 3, 2024
According to court documents, the judge only considered what the SEC wrote because of the lack of contrary evidence presented in the claims. Grewal criticized the SEC’s “cunning” strategy of “fighting against a wide open door.”
The CLO said the SEC’s seeking a default judgment means “those with the greatest incentives and access to information that undermines their case never have a chance.”
COIN is trading at $222.33 in the hourly chart. Source: COIN on TradingView.com
Featured image from Unsplash.com, chart from TradingView.com